Pregnancy, motor disability, and mental retardation. Difficult questions must be asked. 12

Pregnancy, motor disability, and mental retardation. Difficult questions must be asked. 12

Can we help?

Leading expert in high-risk obstetrics and maternal-fetal medicine, Dr. Marc Dommergues, MD, explains the complex challenges of pregnancy with motor and intellectual disabilities, detailing the critical need for multidisciplinary care, prenatal genetic counseling, and specialized parenting support systems to ensure positive outcomes for both mother and child.

Navigating Pregnancy and Parenthood with Physical and Intellectual Disabilities

Jump To Section

Multidisciplinary Care Approach

Dr. Marc Dommergues, MD, emphasizes that managing pregnancy in women with genetic diseases like myopathy requires a comprehensive multidisciplinary approach. These conditions often affect multiple organ systems, including the lungs and heart, necessitating coordinated care from various medical specialists. The primary goal has evolved from simply ensuring safe delivery for both mother and baby to addressing long-term quality of life and parenting capabilities.

Parenting Support for Disabilities

Practical parenting challenges represent major concerns for women with physical disabilities. Dr. Dommergues identifies critical questions these women face, including how to breastfeed with hemiplegia, change a baby with distal tremor, or communicate effectively with tetraplegia. These concerns often go unspoken because patients may hesitate to discuss them openly with their healthcare providers, creating a significant gap in prenatal counseling and support.

Environmental Adaptations for Parenthood

A specialized institution focused on "parenting support for people with a handicap" has become an essential partner in addressing these challenges. Dr. Marc Dommergues, MD, explains that this collaboration introduced the concept of adapted parenthood, which focuses on environmental modifications, learning practical techniques, and sharing experiences within a community of families facing similar circumstances. This support system helps prevent situations where a baby's home environment might be considered inadequate due to the mother's disability.

Research on Mother-Child Interactions

Although not yet published, Dr. Dommergues describes groundbreaking research comparing interactions between mothers with motor disabilities and their children against control groups. The study revealed that while difficulties exist, they are not substantially different from challenges experienced by non-disabled mothers, particularly those with premature infants. This research provides valuable insights for developing more effective support strategies for disabled parents.

Intellectual Disability Complexities

The situation becomes significantly more complex when intellectual disability or mental retardation accompanies physical limitations. Dr. Marc Dommergues, MD, identifies this combination as a growing challenge in maternal-fetal medicine. While individuals with mental disabilities rightly assert their capacity for parenthood, they must also confront two critical realities: the potential heritability of their condition and their ability to provide adequate child-rearing support.

Genetic Counseling Importance

Genetic counseling becomes particularly crucial for couples where one or both partners have intellectual disabilities. With continuous gene discovery advancing each year, Dr. Dommergues stresses the importance of evaluating both members of the couple to assess inheritance risks. This proactive approach enables informed family planning decisions and appropriate medical interventions when needed.

Pre-Pregnancy Discussions

Addressing parenthood possibilities before pregnancy presents particularly difficult ethical and practical challenges. Dr. Marc Dommergues, MD, describes emerging collaborative efforts with adult and pediatric psychiatrists at a Paris hospital clinic called the CIC. While experience in this area remains limited and growing, Dr. Dommergues acknowledges the complexity of determining appropriate courses of action for these sensitive situations, reflecting the evolving nature of disability-inclusive reproductive care.

Full Transcript

Dr. Marc Dommergues, MD: If you consider motor disability, again, this is an immense field. In this hospital, we're not very familiar with the most common types, for example, people who had a spinal cord injury. We tend to deal more with people who have genetic diseases, with myopathy, for example. We deal with diseases that tend to affect all systems—the lungs, the heart, etc. This requires a multidisciplinary approach from the medical point of view.

But a few years ago, we were just happy with bringing women and babies alive for delivery. Then we realized that there was a life after delivery. How were women going to cope with a kid? We realized that this was a major question that women were asking themselves, but maybe they did not always dare to discuss it.

How am I going to breastfeed if I've got hemiplegia? How am I going to change my baby if I have a distal tremor? How am I going to communicate with my kid if I have tetraplegia? These are major questions.

We work with a special institution that helps disabled people to adapt as parents: "Parenting support for people with a handicap." This institution is our partner. It introduced us to a concept of adapted parenthood. It is based on adapting the environment, on learning tricks, on sharing the experience with other families.

We have the feeling that it became a great help. It especially helped us to avoid those situations in which one could fear the environment in which the baby is born would not be adequate. This is complicated, because we know that there is a tension between those who care for the mothers and those who care for the kids.

At least in our country, there's a constant fear that the environment in which a child develops is not optimal when the mother is severely disabled. Of course, our fight has always been to encourage those women. Maybe we are a bit over-optimistic sometimes, but we tried to know more about this.

To put things in a very simple way, this has not been published so far, but we studied the interactions between mothers with motor disability and their kids and compared them to controls.

Dr. Anton Titov, MD: There were difficulties, but situations were not much different from the difficulties that non-disabled women experience, for example, when they have premature babies. It's not easy, but it's possible, of course, provided this is a motor disability.

Things may be far more complicated when there is a motor disability plus a mental disability. The problem is not that you have a motor disability; the problem is intellectual or mental retardation. This is a big problem.

It's a problem that more and more patients are facing. It's very difficult. On the one hand, people with a mental disability tend to say that they can become parents like other people. On the other hand, it's important that they be aware of two things.

Their disease may be an inherited condition. More and more genes are discovered every single year. This makes it important to see the two members of the couple and to offer genetic counseling anyway.

Then there's the question of discussing parenthood before pregnancy. It's a very, very difficult matter. We are starting trying to help couples. We're doing that with the help of a group of adult and pediatric psychiatrists in a hospital in Paris; the clinic is called the CIC.

We have very little experience for the moment. It's a growing experience. The only thing I can tell you is that it's very difficult. We are not able to say what should or should not be done because this is a very new experience for us.

Disability is an important topic. I think you've covered a lot of very important questions.

Dr. Anton Titov, MD: So thank you very much.